Jess Kovach

Accountability Means the Outcomes Change

A committee decides someone is a problem because of how they come across. On the word that grades the company’s exposure and never grades you.

On this page
  1. The room has two moves, and it will make one of them
  2. The best-known study about silence is a story nobody checked
  3. We named the comfortable one compliance
  4. The cost does not disappear. It moves.
  5. Sounds protective, becomes embedded, becomes invisible
  6. A standard you cannot move is a standard you can fail
  7. The third move

A committee sits down to calibrate ratings. A name comes up, and the conversation moves from what they delivered to how they come across. Four people in that room know the record does not support it.

Nobody says anything.

The meeting ends on time. Nobody broke a rule. Everybody had a reason. The rating stood.

The problem is not the person in the file. It is the meeting.

The room has two moves, and it will make one of them

The first is to default to character. They are good, everyone agrees they are good, they just need to work on how they come across. Offer a coach. Fund it. The cost of the conversation becomes theirs to absorb, and they will accept it with grace, because they have read the room and know that disagreement will not improve their standing. Their output will not change, because their output was never the issue. What will change is what it costs them to produce it.

The second is to default to grace. We value different styles. We should make room for people who communicate differently. Write a warm note in the record, rate them as fully meeting expectations, and resolve to think about how to support people who operate that way. Now the cost is the room’s to absorb, which sounds better and is not, because nothing about how the room evaluates has changed. Six months from now the same room has the same conversation about the same person.

Both moves are made by decent people. Both feel like the natural next thought. And both leave the meeting exactly as it was, which is why the meeting keeps producing this conversation.

The best-known study about silence is a story nobody checked

Psychologists call the mechanism the bystander effect. The more people who witness something, the less likely any single one of them acts, because each assumes somebody else will. The person beside you is closer. Someone has surely handled it. There is a process for this and it belongs to whoever owns it.

The most famous illustration of that finding is a story about thirty-eight New Yorkers who watched a woman murdered and did nothing. Researchers went back to the record in 2007 and found no evidence there were thirty-eight witnesses, no evidence they saw the murder, and no evidence they did nothing. It ran in the textbooks for forty years, repeated by people who never checked.

The best-known account of people who watched and said nothing is itself a record nobody read.

That parable was easy to carry because it happened to strangers, at night, on a street none of us were standing on. The version that runs at work has a calendar invite and a document trail.

And somebody wrote the rule the room is applying. Every pay gap that holds. Every promotion bar that moved after someone cleared it. Every rule about who reads as professional and who gets coached on tone. Somebody drafted each one, somebody reviewed it, somebody put it in the handbook and somebody else approved the handbook. Those are the architects. They are not a mystery and they are not the majority.

Everyone else gets a decision. Not a role in a diagram. A decision, in a specific room, on a specific day, with two options in it. One of them costs you something. The other one is comfortable and leaves the arrangement exactly as you found it.

We named the comfortable one compliance

It is an institution’s word. Compliance measures whether the organization did enough to avoid liability. It has never measured whether anyone was helped or harmed, because that is a different word.

Accountability means the outcomes actually change.

The comfortable choice arrives wearing the language of obligation, and the word for it grades the company’s exposure and never grades you.

Here is what it does not grade. You forwarded the memo to the person who was going to sign it anyway. You signed the review. You approved the transfer. You typed a reason into the field. You sat in the room while the sentence stood, and you let it stand.

None of that is watching. Every one of them is a hand on the thing at the moment the thing needed a hand.

The cost does not disappear. It moves.

This is not a claim about character. Most people who stay quiet are not cowards, and telling them they are will not move a single one of them. They are doing math, and the math is real.

Speaking costs the person who speaks. Silence costs someone else, later, invisibly, in an amount nobody records.

Not everyone in that room has had this happen to them, and a person who has never been read that way has less reason to hear it happening to someone else. Of the people who do hear it, not everyone will say so. Neither of those is a character flaw. Both are conditions the meeting produced, and a rating only has to clear one room.

Not because someone designed it that way. Because no one designed it otherwise.

That is a cost transfer. The structure produced a cost, and rather than carry it, the structure moved it onto a person, where it sits unmeasured. No line item. No owner. No report. The organization’s numbers look fine because the cost was never in them.

Sounds protective, becomes embedded, becomes invisible

Compliance did not begin as a way to avoid answering for outcomes. It began as a protective idea, and protective ideas drift the same way every time. It sounds protective. It becomes embedded. It becomes invisible.

Once a word is invisible, nobody argues with it. The training is completed. The policy is attested. The dashboard is green.

Somewhere inside that green there is a person who has been told their communication is a problem, and four people who know the record does not support it, and none of that reaches the number, because the number was never built to hold it.

There is a one-question test for whether any of it is real. If the program vanished overnight, would the system go back to what it was doing? Ask what your compliance program is actually measured on. If the answer is completion and attestation, those are activities the program performs on itself. Remove the program and the calibration meeting runs exactly as it ran before, because the meeting was never what the program was measuring.

A structure that produces harm cannot run on its architects alone. It needs a much larger group to move it along, and that group is not incidental to the design. It is the load-bearing element.

A standard you cannot move is a standard you can fail

This is hard to argue inside an organization because the standard is the organization’s own. Values are written by the same people who decide when to compress them. A stated value that bends in a bad quarter was never a floor. It was a preference with good branding.

A right is different from a favor. A favor is granted, and whoever grants it can stop. A right is delivered, and when it is not delivered, the failure sits with the delivery rather than with the person asking.

That is why a rights floor is more useful in practice than a values statement. You did not set it. They cannot move it.

A standard you cannot move is a standard you can fail. That is not a weakness in the standard. It is the entire point.

The third move

There is a third move, and one person in that room can make it without anyone’s permission.

It is not a policy change and it is not a campaign. It is refusing to be the part of the mechanism the structure was counting on. In the calibration meeting, it is one sentence: the record does not support that.

That sentence costs the person who says it. It costs less than the alternative, which is a rating that stands because the room was quiet, and a person who spends the next year developing a deficit they do not have.

Naming the structure is not complaining. It is the first move of a diagnostic.

So the question is not whether the system is rigged. That question is comfortable, because it has no address.

Is this the person or the structure?

Answer it in the room you are standing in, on the Tuesday when you can see it and nobody has said anything yet.

The structure is counting on you. Not to build anything. Just to be quiet while it works.


If you recognize the room, the next question is which one you are looking at: the structure, or your own habits inside it. Those take different answers, and most communication-style feedback mixes them.

The Naming Work separates them. Fifteen questions across four clusters, scored twice: what the system is doing, and where awareness gives you leverage. You get both scores read together, and a next move based on the pair.

Name it before you change it.

Get the diagnostic at app.kovachconsultants.com/the-naming-work

References

Manning, R., Levine, M., & Collins, A. (2007). The Kitty Genovese murder and the social psychology of helping: The parable of the 38 witnesses. American Psychologist, 62(6), 555–562. doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.62.6.555

Latané, B., & Darley, J. M. (1968). Group inhibition of bystander intervention in emergencies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 10(3), 215–221. doi.org/10.1037/h0026570

workplace systems · the practice

All posts